So I’ve had more than week to digest and go through the data and contacts I made at BarCamp NewsInnovation Philadelphia., and wow, was there some great stuff and smart, passionate people.
For me, the point of the news innovation movement has not been about talking and creating new ideas. It’s been about action and collaboration. I think most people got that at the BarCamp.
With that said, here were my big takeaways, and I’ll go into more detail on some of them below:
- Collaboration – although messy and hard to replicate – is vital to success. Collaboration solves the filter failure issue. (Originally I couldn’t find the right link to the ‘filter failure’ post until Scott Karp posted this).
- Organizations need to commit to innovation, despite the cost, and the sharing of those innovations leads to smarter ideas in the future
- We have to better create more relevant user experiences across print, digital, mobile and the next platform to come
- Sales staffs at media companies still have no idea how to sell or be creative when it comes to digital advertising, business models or call-to-action types of monetization efforts.
- Three dudes – Sean Blanda, Brian James Kirk and Christopher Wink – who run Technically Philly offer a great lesson on a digital startup.
- Not many of the news innovators work for media companies. A lot of the talent is working for companies trying to help the media industry evolve.
One concept that I have not yet fully explored, but agree with came from Ted Mann via Twitter: @turkeymonkey: #BCNIPhilly takeaway No. 1: If you’re creating a blog or website, forget about building your business model on advertising”
The comprehensive roundup of the reaction from #bcniphilly gives a better overview of the day than I can, but I want to go into more specifics about topics that resonated with me.
Collaboration
Media organizations must learn and be better at collecting and curating content based on topic in a collaborative, networked way. Those companies are only one voice and there are hundreds of others out there locally who like to produce, consume and share. We need to find those people, engage them, work with them, publish them and celebrate their successes within this newly formed network.
Scott Karp of Publish2 talked about collaboration in general at #bcniphilly (which you can also view), and also what his company is doing to try and make it easier for media companies.
We believe citizen journalism is part of a larger process where professional journalists still play the vital role they always have. The key is to enable dynamic and ongoing collaboration between citizens and professional journalists, where citizens can become a true practical extension of the newsroom.
In all this, it was clear that we need to recognize the wetness of collaboration. It’s messy and there is no perfect formula to make it work. But when it does, it’s magic.
Someone working alone with really cheap tools has a reasonable hope of carving out enough of the cognitive surplus, enough of the desire to participate, enough of the collective goodwill of the citizens to create a resource you couldn’t have imagined existing five years ago. – Clay Shirky at Web 2.0 Expo
Innovation
Steven King, the editor of innovation for washingtonpost.com, spoke about the web ninja’s team and about some of the past and future projects they are working on. View his presentation and watch a video interview with him.
The team is made of up only three people. Their job is to, as his presentation says, rapidly develop innovative ways to present news and information. They also work with a three-person ad innovation team.
“If we are not looking toward the future, than we have no future,” King said. “It is very important to have these types of discussions and be flexible to be able to work with whatever comes next.”
In some ways that’s what I meant when I wrote about “What are the jobs to be done” saying if it is to solely make money now, than we will fail. Yes, we need revenue to continue to operate but we need that three –person team, or whatever it is, of smart, talented people looking toward the future. If we do that, I think instead of being way behind, we’ll be more agile and better equipped to address issues when they arise.
The startup mentality
As I noted above #bcniphilly organizers Sean Blanda, Christopher Wink and Brian James Kirk started a web site, Technically Philly, that for me offered some good lessons for the startup mentality we need right about now.
Whitney Rhodes sums it up pretty well on how to get started by finding 1) a need 2) a community based on that need and 3) a way to reach out and fulfill said need for said community.
Technically Philly suggests you tackle a community you already consider yourself a part of. Technically’s founders, three recent college graduates and tech gurus, did just that. They saw a tech coverage hole in Philadelphia and created TechnicallyPhilly.com to fill it.
The reason why I mention this mentality is because it plays into the moving away from the institutional brand to the person brand. Our society and industry seems to be shifting to that mentality and having the skills and mindset of a startup is going to play a big role in that.
Depicting reader comments in a visual way
April 27, 2009 by wemediaguru
We’re all aware that washingtonpost.com has been able to do some cool stuff in recent years. One of their web ninjas, Steven King – editor of innovations – presented at BarCamp News Innovation Philadelphia and one of the lesser known ideas caught my attention.
It had to do with the way comments were visual shown in the WP’s online feature called OnBeing. It is the first time I’ve seen where comments were displayed this way and thought it was pretty cool.
In the photo above, the main piece of content is the image of the kid in a red and white striped shirt. The boxes connect to the main content area are the reader comments. You see some boxes are larger and some are closer to the main content than others.
“The larger comment threats get closer to the original content,” King said. “The comments on the peripheral of the topic stay on the outside. The more conversation pieces that break off the more value the conversations are.”
King said the three-person web ninja team is very visual, thus the idea of representing comments in a visible way. Not everyone likes it, but I do.
Posted in media | Tagged BarCamp NewsInnovation, comments, visual, washingtonpost | 2 Comments »